The ex-boyfriend Sara Mesa slept with a month prior to Married at First Sight Australia 2024 is allegedly a different man from the one she caught up with during the show.

ICYMI: The March 6 dinner party fully exploded when Eden Harper and Jayden Eynaud dropped the bombshell that Sara had seen her former flame during filming.

Her husband, Tim Calwell, later dished to the group that Sara had slept with her ex “a month before” filming the show.

Do you have a tip about MAFS 2024? Email tips@sodramaticmedia.com

sara mesa married at first sight ex boyfriend
The ex-boyfriend Sara Mesa slept with a month prior to Married at First Sight 2024 is a different man from the one she caught up with during the show. Source: Nine

However, a source close to Sara has revealed that the ex-boyfriend in question and the one she slept with just before the show are actually two separate men.

“Sara told Tim privately that she had slept with an ex a month ago, but it was a different ex to the one she had caught up with and who was mentioned at the dinner party,” they told So Dramatic!.

“Tim told everyone she slept with her ex a month ago while she was out of the room. When she came back, Stephen [Stewart] asked her if she had, and she just said yes.”

The source added: “It wasn’t even the ex she hung out with, but she didn’t want it to look like she was lying by arguing about something else.”

Sara confessing to being complicit in an affair was ‘completely out of context’ on Married at First Sight

During the dinner party, the Columbian-born bride seemingly put her foot in it when she appeared to admit to sleeping with her ex-partner while he had a long-term girlfriend.

However, one of Sara’s co-stars said this confession was taken “completely out of context”.

Sara had told Tim in confidence early on in the experiment that when she and her ex were hooking up in the past, he had a girlfriend,” they explained.

tim calwell married at first sight
Sara had told Tim Calwell about her history with her ex “in confidence”. Source: Nine

“However, she didn’t know he had a girlfriend at the time.”

The MAFS 2024 participant then said Sara’s commentary was edited to make it “look like she’s okay with cheating“.

“Sara said, ‘Yeah, he did [have a girlfriend], but I didn’t know’,” they recalled. “But they just cut the ‘I didn’t know’ part.”

Pesky producers!

Why Sara Mesa really walked out of the Married at First Sight dinner party

A production insider also dished some tea about the most hectic dinner party yet.

While it appeared that Sara was fumbling for excuses, they say this isn’t how it went down on the night.

“The dinner party was every single person yelling over each other and at Sara, not letting her get a word in,” they claimed.

“But they muted everyone’s mics in the final cut to make out like Sara was stammering around and fumbling over her words and creating this web of lies.”

eden jayden mafs 2024
The cast “yelling” at Sara was allegedly cut to “make out like Sara was creating this web of lies”. Source: Nine

According to the insider, the final edit “cut out everyone yelling at her“.

“It made it look like everyone said their piece calmly, but it was mayhem. That’s why she walked out.”

MAFS participants claim Sara Mesa was hooking up with her ex-boyfriend during filming

While Sara alleged her catch-up with her ex was friendly and in a group setting, some of her co-stars aren’t buying it.

“Sara and her ex had been sleeping together for five years after they broke up, even though he had a new girlfriend,” one alleged.

Meanwhile, a second participant said they were “definitely still romantic leading up to MAFS“.

“And let’s be real, during MAFS too,” they claimed.

Eden only told the PG version of what she knew. She said she had more things to tell.”

And we’re waiting with bated breath for the extended version!

Want even more goss? Listen to the So Dramatic! podcast with Megan Pustetto below!

Know something that we don’t? Spill the tea here!

Get the tea first! Follow So Dramatic! on Instagram and tune in on Mondays to get your reality tea fix with the So Dramatic! podcast with Megan Pustetto.