Love Island Australia 2021’s Mitch Hibberd may have walked away with $25k and arm-in-arm with Tina Provis, but that doesn’t mean the scandals have stopped!

As reported in episode 130 of the So Dramatic! podcast, host Megan Pustetto revealed that the serial DM pest has even more of a history than we first expected!

mitch hibberd
Mitch Hibberd has been called out for DMing a 17-year-old on Instagram. Source: Channel 9.

What Is the New Texting Scandal Mitch Hibberd Is Caught Up In?

Thanks to a So Dramatic! source, who has received messages from the AFL player, we have even more insight!

Hello, nothing crazy but I thought if you’d received other claims from girls it all adds up,” the source said. “Mitch messaged me in 2016 originally, maybe wouldn’t have known my age.”

The source then revealed that he messaged again the following year and the conversation went a little something like this:

“How old are you?” he asked.

“Take a stab in the dark”, she said.



Then Mitch asked if she was: “19? 20? 21? 22? Am I getting warmer?” he asked.

mitch emily love island australia 2021
A source had revealed the text exchange she had with Mitch. Source: Channel 9.

“Colder,” she said.

Mitch then guessed “30”, however, he was 100% going the wrong way. Turns out, our source was 17 at the time!

While this was a while ago, so we’re not going to @ him with pitchforks, Mitch then said: “Age is just a number we will settle with 20. When are you coming over?” Eep!

Yikes! Let’s just hope this behaviour stays in the past!

Big Brother Australia’s Charlotte McCristal Revealed Mitch Slid Into her DM’s Too!

Big Brother Australia’s Charlotte McCristal revealed back in November that Mitch had slid into her DMs too!

When Emily Ward entered the villa, it was revealed that Mitch had struck up a convo with her prior to the show. Then, a woman on TikTok came forward and claimed she had also received some cheeky messages from him too!

Then, Charlotte came forward, saying that she too had received “persistent” DMs from Mitch.

Charlotte McCristal revealed that Mitch Hibberd slid into her DMs as well! Source: Instagram.
Charlotte McCristal revealed that Mitch slid into her DMs as well! Source: Instagram.

Commenting underneath an article on our So Dramatic! Insta titled: “Love Island’s Mitch Hibberd Exposed as a F*ckboy On TikTok For “Messaging Half of Melbourne”, she wrote: “Omg I ain’t the only one.”

As reported in episode 117 of the So Dramatic! podcast, host Megan Pustetto took a leaf out of Mitch’s book and slid into Charlotte’s DMs.

Tilly [Whitfield] and I were laughing at these old messages,” she said. “I was so blunt back but omg he was persistent – I would have given up!“

Check out the full screenshots here!

Want even more goss? Listen to episode 130 of the So Dramatic! podcast with Megan Pustetto below!

Know something that we don’t? Spill the tea here!

Get the tea first! Follow So Dramatic! on Instagram and tune in on Mondays to get your reality tea fix with the So Dramatic! podcast with Megan Pustetto.